Are you looking for the Best Restaurants in Hamptons Bays? Look no further! You most likely did a search on the internet and found this page and you are interested in knowing where to eat tonight. Below I compiled a list of the best Restaurants in Hampton Bays, NY that I have actually dined at. Let me start off by stating that Hampton Bays has great restaurants that attract people from all over the Hamptons. It also has a large number of waterfront restaurants some of which provide spectacular sunsets. I will continue to update this list as I dine at new restaurants in Hampton Bays.
Cowfish
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-594-3868
Cowfish has one of the most spectacular views of Shinnecock Bay from the inside dining room and its vast outdoor space. The menu features interesting twists on traditional coastal cuisine. Grab a drink at the outdoor bar or upstairs bar while enjoying the sunset and then grab a table in their beautiful dining room. You can also take the Tiki Shuttle boat to Rumba. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
Rumba
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-594-3544
The sister restaurant to Cowfish, Rumba is a special dining spot serving up a unique combination of Island-inspired food, premium handcrafted libations, happy staffers, and a low-key vibe. You can pull up by boat or valet park. I love the tacos and the Coconut Risotto. Enjoy the Tiki Shuttle boat to Cowfish. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
78 Foster
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-594-3967
78 Foster Restaurant & Bar has replaced BackBar Grille in Hampton Bays. Enjoy Indoor and Outdoor dining combined with spectacular sunsets. 78 Foster has a fresh seafood selection combined with live music – making this place a great night out. Tell Helene (owner of 78 Foster) that Dave sent you. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
The Hamlet
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-8811
This local gem is a great place to grab your morning coffee, newspaper, and bagel, or fresh fruit, milk eggs, and other market staples. Newly renovated with a crisp nautical feel. Animals Welcome!
The Inn Spot on the Bay
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-1200
Legendary brunch and dinner provided by a French-trained chef Colette. Amazing sunset views overlooking the Shinnecock Bay. Come here for sunset cocktails and then enjoy your dinner inside their intimate dining room. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
Sundays on the Bay
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-2611
For a casual lunch or dinner, coming from the beach or the boat, Sundays is a can’t miss. Their twin lobster specials are a staple of Summer Dining in the Hamptons. This is a great place to watch the game or meet friends for a drink. Great tables overlooking the Marina with fantastic sunsets. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
Oaklands
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-6900
The Gold standard of waterfront dining, Oakland’s offers innovative seafood & steaks in an elegant nautical setting. Stunning indoor & outdoor dining overlooking the Marina, with an outdoor bar featuring Live entertainment on weekends. Come here for Sunset Dining. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
Edgewater
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-723-2323
Some of the most creative dining available anywhere in the Hamptons. The Edgewater staff provides exceptional service. Great water views of the Shinnecock Bay. Gorgeous Sunsets combined with candlelit tables offer an inviting setting for the array of Italian fare, seafood dishes, sizzling steaks & gourmet pizzas. Don’t miss it! Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
Shuckers
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-905-8292
Shucker’s Lobster & Clam Bar is a family-friendly, beach restaurant located blocks from the ocean in Hampton Bays. They offer casual outside dining and plenty of room on the open front lawn for games and relaxing with the kids.
Villa Paul
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-3261
A Hampton Bays institution, famously featuring the best Long Island duck anywhere in the country. Located on Main Street, Villa Paul offers an old-world charm. A fantastic spot for quiet family-style dining. Truly a Hamptons classic.
Buckley’s Inn Between
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-7197
Buckley’s Inn Between offers a warm, friendly atmosphere and a “touch of Ireland” in the heart of Hampton Bays. Family-friendly, with American & Irish fare. For the after-dinner crowd, step into the pub to watch a game on the big screen TV or play a game of darts.
Matsulin
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-8838
Featuring specialty dishes from Malaysia, China, Japan, Thailand, and Vietnam, each is a precise representation of the fare of its respective country. Located in a former bank, the interior makes for a romantic evening.
Out of the Blue
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-728-3474
Enjoy fresh-caught seafood in this casual dining experience. Take out or sit down. Specializing in cold and hot smoking techniques, these artisans are sure to impress. Children and adults will love picking their lobster from the live lobster tank. This is my go-to lunch spot!
Canal Café
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-723-2155
Hidden behind Surfside Modern Yachts, directly on the Shinnecock canal. Watch the boats return from cruising the Peconic as you experience a colorful menu and lively local bar. Always check the chalkboard for interesting specials and be sure to sit outside. Life is good at the Canal Cafe.
1 North Steakhouse
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-594-3419
One of the best steak houses east of New York City. A great bar, featuring signature Martinis to compliment some of the nest hand-selected meats anywhere in the Hamptons. Finish your meal with a decadent dessert. All served family-style.
Centro Trattoria & Bar
Website
Yelp Reviews
631-594-5744
Centro Trattoria & Bar is a farm to fork Italian restaurant. All of their menu items are made in-house using many of the East End’s local, in-season produce. Centro incorporates family recipes including fresh homemade pasta, individual pizzas from their wood-burning oven. Try the clams oreganata and grilled octopus – you won’t be disappointed. Top of my list of Restaurants in Hampton Bays.
